Dogwood/Oak Tree at Middle Island Country Club

Showed up 20 minutes before our tee time after it had just rained for 45 minutes and they wouldn’t let us out. We were going to walk an 18 but it didn’t matter to them. They sent us away and didn’t offer anything in return just said go deal with GolfNow for your refund. We drove down the road to Spring Lake and were able to play luckily. Weather was great after the rain shower and there was no reason to not let us go out.

It’s was not worth $90. Small shelf of random snacks and drinks. Bar didn’t open till 1030 am which is only place you can get real food. They had a snack cart going around with the same amenities. I asked if there was a snack shack, which she acknowledged, but failed to tell me it opened later, even though I was on the 9th and told her I would just go there. Staff wasn’t super nice nor mean. Very average experience. They had a ranger that should’ve had a slow paced group speed it up off the bat, but he pretty much stayed around the turn/ first tee. Course was in great shape. Very tough course especially the greens, so there was def a challenge. It was a nice place to play one time, but for the value and lack of amenities, probably just a one time thing..

The course is in great shape. It’s 3 9 holes so pace of play wasn’t a huge issue especially compared to other public courses on LI. The pro shop was nicely stocked but they offer zero food . The driving range is not maintained at all and the bathrooms were overflowing with feces water by 9am . So moral of the story, the golf was great but make sure you eat first and don’t need to use the indoor facilities.

Over booked leading to horrible pace

Over priced

Bunkers filled with rocks and roots. Not to mention are closer to mud than sand.

Greens need to cut so the ball actually rolls

Wouldn’t play here again til prices are cut

Played on a beautiful Monday afternoon. Im a 30 handicap and this course was built for players like me. Fairways are very forgiving as they are wide with a few scattered bunkers for errant long hitters.

Rough was high so jeep it on the fairway.

Greens in good condition and true to line.

Good value for the average golfer.

I loved this course even though without a starter when you play 18 you have to ask where the 10th hole is.

I really enjoyed myself. Was slightly rushed with a group of two driving up on us every hole. great place to at least practice early in the morning or late in evening.

Was hoping to get out to play golf go to Corus Star said if we are ready we can go which was a few minutes early and the rest of the day was great thank you goodbye

Clearly they’re injection some money into this place and it shows. Keeps getting better. New signage on tee boxes, clearing trees away to really open up some of the longer holes and generally tidying up the entire course. Greens in great shape and fairways are excellent.

Better than used to be. Guys in head of us real slow, not the places fault. Greens were being aerated I think. Had potential

Insanely expensive for one of the worst courses on Long Island. Truly shocking. Avoid at all costs. I never leave reviews and got compelled to do so based on rude staff (starter), slow pace of play 5.5hr round, pretty much putting on sand and not well kept.

Started off with a snippy starter.. could be a bit easygoing. Could of been a bad morning for him. A lot of work being done to make the club house and around it new and updated. So no lunch just snacks. However course was nice greens were just addresses so Sandy and wet but dryer up as it got closer to noon. I’d definitely come and play again. Good first round

Good course fun to play good pace and variety, currently renovating club house