Top courses in Michigan's Gaylord Golf Mecca: Six (and a half) can't-miss options

Golf in Michigan is arguably the best in the nation. And if there were a year-round golf season, there would be no argument about it at all.

In this dual-peninsula state, surrounded by nearly one-fifth of the world's fresh water, you'll find more public golf courses per capita than in any other state and more five-star and four-star courses, too -- so Michigan has both quantity and quality.

When golfers who know Michigan talk about golf, one area always comes up first: The Gaylord Golf Mecca. The "Mecca" is larger than just Gaylord and includes 17 courses, five resort properties and 20 hotels, so there is plenty of room both on and off the course during the precious summer months. All these choices can be overwhelming, though. So if you're making your way to the Gaylord Golf Mecca for the first time, here are six (and a half) must-plays to get you acclimated to some of the best golf in the country:

1. The Tribute at the Otsego Club

One of the landmark golf and ski resorts in Gaylord is the Otsego Club and Resort. In 2003, the 7,347-yard Tribute Course, designed by Rick Robbins and Gary Koch, opened to rave reviews. Situated on more than 1,000 acres of land, many holes are routed through wetlands, including nos. 5-8, all of which run along the Sturgeon River. Most holes feature elevated tees and lots of visual slight-of-hand, which produces some of the most memorable shots in the area.

2. Elk Ridge Golf Club

Just less than 35 miles east of Gaylord, the sleepy town of Atlanta is nestled into the dense woodland. And bedding down in those woods is one of the largest elk herds in the lower 48 -- the namesake elk of the 7,072-yard Jerry Matthews masterpiece, Elk Ridge Golf Club. In 1992, Elk Ridge was named the second best new course to open in America, and it remains one of the most unique. The layout through elk-ridden woodlands (during rutting season, the greens are roped off to limit elk damage) features numerous doglegs and wetlands. Club selection is key here, as positioning off the tee will usually be the difference between an easy par and a hard bogey.

3. Black Forest Golf Course

World-famous course architect Tom Doak first explored his signature minimalist proclivities at Black Forest Golf Course. Opened in 1992, it was named the best new public course in America and has perennially been rated as one of the best in the state. The 7,044-yard track starts off with five or so of its hardest holes, so tee up and man up -- birdie chances will come later. Above all, you'll notice the natural bunkering style, which in the early '90s helped revolutionize golf course design.

4. Fazio Premier at Treetops

Treetops Resort has been the focal point of northern Michigan golf, including the site of the defunct (but perhaps soon-to-return) Par-3 Shootout (see more about that below). With four 18-hole championship courses and one spectacular, par-3 nine holer (again, see below), visitors to Gaylord could spend their entire time in the Gaylord Golf Mecca at Treetops. Everyone has a favorite Treetops track, but the Tom Fazio-designed Premier Course might have the most fans. At 6,832 yards, and with wide, bowl-like fairways, it's player friendly -- it fits the eye, and the large, undulating greens are readable and puttable.

5. Rick Smith Tradition at Treetops

Treetops Resort is owned by golf coach to the stars Rick Smith. Smith also designed a few of the courses at Treetops, including the often-overlooked Tradition Course. At just 6,467 (par 70/71) from the tips, the Tradition was laid out so that players could walk it (unlike most of the other courses in the Gaylord Golf Mecca). Despite the diminutive length, the Tradition has a very nice collection of long-ish par 4s (like the 491-yard 11th). Best of all, the greens here are the fairest, most playable of all the Treetops courses.

6. Black Lake Golf Club

Black Lake Golf Club in Onaway is a bit of a hike from Gaylord (just less than an hour north), but it's technically part of the Golf Mecca, and it's well worth the drive. This 7,030-yard Rees Jones layout features one isolated hole after another, replete with natural sand waste areas, wildlife and wetlands. Owned and operated by the UAW, Black Lake feels like a private club, choc-full of amenities, including a 773-yard, par-27 "Little Course" that's perfect for families. All of the greens offer both areal and run-up approach routes, and despite the surrounding woods and marshes, wide fairways and generous landing areas make Black Lake playable and enjoyable for golfers of all levels.

6.5. Threetops at Treetops Resort

The made-for-TV Par-3 Shootout put Gaylord onto the national golf radar, and when Lee Trevino aced the seventh hole for $1,010,000 in 2001, it was a shot heard round the golf world. So don't poo-poo a par 3. Threetops packs as many thrills into nine short holes as many courses do into 18 full-length ones. And considering that some of the best players in the world have been challenged by the 100-plus foot elevation drops, it is anything but a pushover. Renovations are also underway to bring Threetops back up to television standards, in an attempt to resurrect the Par-3 Shootout.

Kiel Christianson has lived, worked, traveled and golfed extensively on three continents. As senior writer and equipment editor for, he has reviewed courses, resorts, and golf academies from California to Ireland, including his home course, Lake of the Woods G.C. in Mahomet, Ill. Read his golf blog here and follow him on Twitter @GolfWriterKiel.

Related Links

With 17 courses in the Gaylord Golf Mecca, getting a good deal is never a concern. There are price points in all ranges. In fact, a three-day golf trip spending $200 or less on green fees can be done even in high season.
2 Min Read
Other than missing a handful of big-timers, northern Michigan features a list of golf course designers as good as any destination in the country. All the usual suspects who dominate top 100 lists are well represented. But what are the best of the best? Jason Scott Deegan offers up northern Michigan's 10 best "designer" golf courses.
3 Min Read
Northern Michigan's golf scene is spectacular and diverse, but also vast. Jason Scott Deegan offers some pointers to help plan your first trip.
5 Min Read
More from the author
3 Min Read
May 1, 2017
Cobra and Arccos Golf have teamed up to create the COBRA CONNECT feature that is an ultra light-weight sensor to track distance and accuracy. Kiel Christianson reviews it.
2 Min Read
April 28, 2017
Tour Edge Exotics touts the company's "material advantage" in promoting its clubs. Case in point: The new Exotics EX10 Driver features a TSP 910 Beta Ti faceplate. Read the full review here.
2 Min Read
April 27, 2017
Kiel Christianson has some of our favorite golf clothing options for men and women, for the 2017 season.
4 Min Read
April 26, 2017
For a comprehensive club-fitting experience, Kiel Christianson tried out the Club Champion method, which has grown to many major U.S. markets.
2 Min Read
April 19, 2017
Last year, European golf trolley leader BIG MAX introduced a remarkable fold-flat technology in its three-wheeled Autofold FF model. Kiel Christianson reviews the latest model.
4 Min Read
April 11, 2017
Located just outside of Charleston, South Carolina, Wild Dunes Resort features 36 holes beside the Atlantic Ocean designed by Tom Fazio and Mike Strantz.
3 Min Read
November 16, 2022
Las Vegas loves over-the-top luxury. This offer combines some golf with insider access to the 2023 Formula 1 race on the Strip.
8 Min Read
November 20, 2022
GOLF+, an increasingly popular virtual-reality golf video game, brings an impressive simulation of the game into your living room.
1 Min Read
November 17, 2022
How many strokes is Chuck getting, anyway?
1 Min Read
November 7, 2022
The YOC auction raises money to benefit junior golfers.
Load More
Now Reading
Top courses in Michigan's Gaylord Golf Mecca: Six (and a half) can't-miss options