Separating the sport of golf from the game of golf

It has never been easier - or more important - to distinguish between the game the pros play and the one you play.
Rory McIlroy helped elevate the sport of golf at the 2022 RBC Canadian Open, but neither he nor any of his colleagues would be nearly so beloved if not for the game of golf.

It was a weird weekend, but there were plenty of reasons for hope if you're a golf nut.

The PGA Tour's RBC Canadian Open final round was an absolute delight. The final threesome of Rory McIlroy, Justin Thomas and Tony Finau treated viewers to a display of spectacular golf on a classic course, with McIlroy needing to shoot 62 to hold off the other two.

But as satisfying as it was, the PGA Tour's product was only highlight #2 of my golf weekend. The top spot goes to an hour-long range session I got to spend at my home course Sunday morning. I didn't win millions of dollars, I wasn't ferried to and from the tee in a British taxi and to be honest, I didn't even hit that many good shots. But no matter how well the Rorys and Justins play, no matter how much they entertain me when I'm on my couch, and no matter how much money the more venal pros play for on rogue upstart tours, no one will interest me as much as my favorite golfer: me.

I suspect you agree. Whether you have a passing or passionate interest in watching other people play golf, nothing matches the maelstrom of emotions that swirl around your own first-hand experience of the game.

The game of golf, not the sport.

The sport of golf is what you see on TV. It can often be captivating, as it was Sunday, not to mention lucrative for those directly involved. But in the end, the sport of golf is a commercial product developed and calibrated to convert our capacity to be entertained into ever-rising tournament purses, broadcast rights fees, advertising revenue and executive compensation.

The game of golf is far more personal and unique to each person who plays it. It's time with family and friends, time in nature, opportunities to compete even for small stakes, a platform for human connection and the fostering of values like integrity and diligence. It has its own commercial elements, sure, but they're more varied and adaptable to our own aspirations.

The game and the sport of golf are connected, but make no mistake: the sport relies on the game, and not vice versa. If the sport suddenly ceased to exist, the game would go on as it has for centuries. The ongoing disruption of the sport of golf, thanks to the Saudi Arabia-backed LIV Golf organization, is alternately intriguing and upsetting, but it will eventually settle out, and in the end it will have little to no effect - thank goodness - on the game of golf. The success or failure of the LIV Golf tour has zero to do with the sanctity of your Saturday morning game, except as fodder for conversation.

Golf is different from most other popular athletic pursuits in that millions of people who habitually watch its elite version on television also happen to play it themselves. Take, for counterexample, the NFL. A tiny portion of people who watch the Super Bowl have ever strapped on pads and bashed their bodies into others at the line of scrimmage. The vast majority of us have no hope of hoisting three-pointers with the ease of Stephen Curry in the NBA Finals. We cannot and will never smash 98-mile-per-hour fastballs out of ballparks like Aaron Judge does with regularity. The attraction of these spectator sports lies in the fact that most lay fans cannot identify with the experience of playing it themselves.

Golf's appeal is the opposite; context is crucial to understanding. People who don't play the game almost always underestimate how difficult it is. They don't get how mind-blowingly good Justin Thomas is at hitting pinpoint wedge shots, or just how closely Rory McIlroy's ability to drive the ball so far and so straight resembles a superpower. Playing the game ourselves binds us to the efforts of the most famous golfers to do the same and gives us an appreciation that makes us watch.

But in the end, all else being equal, where would we rather be: on the couch or in the arena? I reckon that the vast majority of us would choose the latter, with occasional exceptions like this coming Sunday's U.S. Open final round and the conclusions of the other major championships.

Even so, the strongest urges I have to go play golf or practice always come after watching a thrilling tournament on TV because at the end of the day, I care about my own game most of all. After enjoying the sport of golf, I still desire the game more than anything else. No shotgun starts, no made-up team format and no amount of $4-million, first-place prizes will ever change that fact.

Tim Gavrich is a Senior Writer for GolfPass. Follow him on Twitter @TimGavrich and on Instagram @TimGavrich.
Commented on

Terrific article, and your points about practicing and playing “the game of golf,” as distinct from involvement with the pro sport, are well-taken. I agree with you that golfers underestimate the difficulty of playing the game at a high level, and that playing golf is superior to watching it on TV.

Recently I picked up Hale Irwin’s instructional book, “Smart Golf” (1999), in which the author cites his practice habit of twice a day during tournament weeks, and compares the gap between practice hours of the touring pro versus even the top amateur player. In short, golf is hard work. In several chapters throughout the book, Irwin aligns hard work and intensive mental focus as the key to constantly improving, meeting one’s goals, and playing consistently “smart golf.” So professionals, in effect, tend to make the game look easy, but that is an illusion. Justin Thomas and Rory McIroy really are playing the game at a level, every day and on nearly every shot, that we are very much unfamiliar with.

A great study, done by Malcolm Gladwell in his book “Outliers: The Story of Success,” in revealed how, for example, accomplished violinists (the kind who play in symphony orchestras) became so accomplished. Talent was important, but Gladwell came up with, in chapter 2, the “10,000 hour rule,” which says that to be exceptionally good at anything that is difficult, and those who hope to be “world-class experts” invest 10,000 hours of serious, focused practice to achieve mastery.

Commented on

I agree. I certainly enjoy watching a close match on the television, but it doesn’t come close to the pleasure of making ‘that shot’ myself!

More from the author
4 Min Read
September 24, 2023
New equipment and fashion - plus a handy tool for fall golf - highlight this month's report.
4 Min Read
September 24, 2023
Tim Gavrich and Jason Scott Deegan go point/counterpoint over whether retaining the cup is a satisfying result.
6 Min Read
September 22, 2023
The 2023 Ryder Cup site seeks to infuse a bit of 'La Dolce Vita' into golf's premier team competition.
2 Min Read
September 21, 2023
The world-class instructor has devised several ingenious solutions to the issues that plague millions of golfers.
2 Min Read
September 20, 2023
The first Solheim Cup in Andalucia comes 26 years after the 1997 Ryder Cup at Valderrama put the Costa del Sol region on the map to global traveling golfers.
1 Min Read
September 13, 2023
Nearly a quarter-century later, it endures.
4 Min Read
September 14, 2023
Here's a look at the history of golf handicaps, how they are calculated, and where you can get one.
5 Min Read
September 13, 2023
Puttr, a new technologically-advanced putting mat, could help you make more putts on the golf course.
4 Min Read
September 11, 2023
Which of the 58 golf resorts in the Caribbean do you dream of visiting for your next tropical winter golf getaway?
3 Min Read
September 4, 2023
Golfers who love to walk should choose their footwear carefully.
Now Reading
Separating the sport of golf from the game of golf