How major championship golf altered Bethpage Black

Renovation prior to the U.S. Open returned the course to prominence, but not all features are as they were meant to be.
Bethpage Black is one of the most popular - and feared - municipal courses in the country.

FARMINGDALE, N.Y. — How much fun would this year’s PGA Championship be if they made the world’s best players line up at 4:45 AM in the parking lot to get a tee time?

That’s the hour I had to get there last month, sitting in my car in a numbered spot (I was No. 29), waiting for the marshal to start handing out bakery tickets at 5 AM that then got me in to the check-in room. State employee Mike Azzue has been working as the parking lot gatekeeper for 15 years and often sees 100-plus cars lined up. On this mid-April morning there were only half that total – partly because tee times on the famed Bethpage Black Course, home of the PGA in a month, didn’t start until 9 AM. They were limiting play in the run up to the championship. Plus it was cold and the ground was wet from an unusually rainy spring.

Some people park out all night waiting for a tee time. No wonder the course seems like an ordeal. By the time you get to the first tee you’re confronted by notice of the challenges that lay ahead. “WARNING – The Black Course Is An Extremely Difficult Course Which We Recommend Only For Highly Skilled Golfers.”

Welcome to public golf at its grandest. The Black Course is the crown jewel of a five-course facility owned and operated by the New York State Department of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation. That’s a government entity, which makes Bethpage State Park a municipal layout. All 1,400 acres of it – 2.2 square miles of prime real estate straddling the border of Nassau and Suffolk Counties, 35 miles due east of Times Square.

Bethpage Black owes its epic scale and character to the glacial action of Ice Age shaping and deposition, ending 14,000 years ago. The broad, dramatic slopes proved perfectly adaptable to golf on a massive scale, which is exactly what course architect A.W. Tillinghast reveled in.

The result, opened in 1936 and admired and feared ever since by public golfers, is a demanding eight-mile walk from first tee to 18th green. For the PGA Championship, May 15-18, the course clocks in at 7,459 yards, par 70. For reference to everyday play, those show on the scorecard as a par 71 with a 77.5 rating and a 155 slope. When it comes to accommodating normal play, the Black Course only makes modest concessions; the forward tees are 6,220 yards, with a 71.4 rating/144 slope for men and 77.8/150 for women. Thus the warning sign.

During the 1970s and 1980s upkeep on the site did not keep pace with the quality of the design, but all that changed in the late 1990s when the U.S. Golf Association determined to rehabilitate the place and hold U.S. Opens there in 2002 and 2009, with the help of designer Rees Jones. The routing of the tees-fairways-greens have remained unchanged, though Jones reshaped all the bunkers from Tillinghast’s original wild shaping to more modern, steep-faced cookie-cutter molding whose formalism is at odds with the site’s native crumply look.

Director of grounds Andy Wilson and crew have the place looking great. Any concerns that the course would not green up and grow out given the earlier spring date compared to recent PGA Championship’s have been allayed. The Poa annua/ryegrass fairways are thick and lush and the Poa/bentgrass greens are in fine form. The roughs will also be thick thanks to the combination of bluegrass, Poa, tall fescue and rye. Of course the most dramatic aesthetic element is the far rough that frames the hole corridors - native fescues combined with Big and Little bluestem.

Tillinghast designed wide fairways. They have been reduced in the restoration to pencil-thin landing areas, 24-26 yards wide. It makes for an awkward look, with those Barbie-doll-waist fairways completely out of scale when sitting amidst the wide corridors and the far-flung array of fairway bunkering. It’s the fate of too many East Coast layouts that they’ve been jury-rigged so forcefully – in a way that reduces most of the fairway bunkering from strategic vitality to overcooked ornamentation.

Nowhere with more irrelevance than at the 411-yard 18th hole, where an endless array of rococo bunkering just reinforces a simple message – the need to hit it straight. For all the length of the place many of today’s leading players will hit half a dozen irons and fairway metals off the tees here.

Bethpage Black is one of the most difficult courses in the country, but New York residents and tourists alike still find the green fees to be an exceptional value for a major championship experience. (Residents: $65-75, Non-residents: $130-150).

The occasional diagonal interlude of sand is a thrill to negotiate. The best example comes at the 478-yard, par-4 fifth hole, where a hundred yard long fairway bunker on the right edges into the already-narrow landing area to make it imperative you hit your tee shot at the precise left-to-right angle. Otherwise the drive will find deep sand on the right or gnarly rough on the left.

The greens, it must be said, are fairly tame. They are not, as often claimed, flat. Rather, they sit unidimensional along a basic continuous cross slope. In some cases if they were rolling any faster they wouldn’t offer any usable hole locations because the ball would not stop. Case in point, the two-tier green at the uphill par-4 15th hole, 484 yards to a putting surface sitting 40 feet above the fairway. It’s the No. 1 handicap hole for good reason, and even with the green having been rebuilt after the 2009 U.S. Open it feels like it’s about to slide off the hill it sits on.

Despite these structural limits, the Black Course offers powerful golf. For the PGA Championship, the par 4s are indeed substantive, averaging 460.5 yards. For everyday players these holes from upward tees are still all you can handle. And there’s something about the view from the tee of the par-5 4th hole, a 511-yard chicane, that makes you marvel the artistry of the classic-era designers. Too bad the shriveled fairway doesn’t properly engage the bunkering.

FARMINGDALE, NY - SEPTEMBER 01: Scenics of the fourth hole at the Bethpage Black Course, home of The Barclays in 2016, on September 1, 2015 in Farmingdale, New York. (Photo by Chris Condon/PGA TOUR)

These judgments aside, Bethpage Black is still one impressive piece of golf ground. And the other four courses there, all part of Bethpage State Park, are each engaging in their own right. There’s a reason the place collectively is home to 225,000 rounds a year. Not everyone in the parking lot is there to play the Black Course.

Nor do you have to dance that parking lot choreography in order to get a tee time. Once the dust from the PGA Championship settles, the park will rely upon a mix of in-person and advanced online access with residents able to book 7 days in advance and non-residents 5 days ahead of time). Green fees are $65 weekday/$75 weekend for New York State residents; $130/$150 for non-residents. There are no carts allowed; you can walk and carry, take a pull cart or book a caddie in advance.

Before trying it yourself, watch for how the pros handle the course during the PGA Championship. Once you’re out there on the Black Course, you’ll be reminded, once again, of the gap between those players and the rest of us. There’s a logic to the warning sign.

The golf courses that earned the best ratings from our community's 140,000-plus reviews throughout 2018
5 Min Read
For years, golfers had to battle busy signals while calling to book a tee time at Bethpage Black. A new online tee time system launched earlier this spring makes getting a tee time easier than ever.
4 Min Read
Every summer, thousands of people set out on trips across their state, region or country, zigzagging to and fro in search of important historical sites. For lovers of golf courses and golf history played out upon them, that is both a noble and doable quest. Certainly, most of the courses that have hosted The Masters, the U.S. Open, The Open and the PGA Championship throughout the years are ultra-private courses reserved for titans of industry and citizens otherwise blessed with seven-digit (or larger) bank accounts.
1 Min Read
The top-rated, publicly accessible courses you can play designed by architect A.W. Tillinghast.
2 Min Read

Veteran golf travel, history and architecture journalist, Bradley S. Klein has written more than 1,500 feature articles on course architecture, resort travel, golf course development, golf history and the media for such other publications as Golfweek, Golf Digest, Financial Times, New York Times and Sports Illustrated. He has published seven books on golf architecture and history, including Discovering Donald Ross, winner of the USGA 2001 International Book Award. In 2015, Klein won the Donald Ross Award for lifetime achievement from the American Society of Golf Course Architects. Follow Brad on Twitter
6 Comments
Default User Avatar
Commented on

I grew up in Bethpage (our house was right across from the 14 hole on the Yellow course). As kids we would sneak on and play as many holes as we could (before the park rangers would chase us). I must have played the Black course 50 times (but I always found the Red Course

Default User Avatar
Commented on

Eight (8) miles from holes 1 to 18? I don't think so. Seven thousand five hundred yards is a bit over 4 miles - not 8 miles as stated.

Default User Avatar
Commented on

He's correct...you need to take the distance between green x and tee y into account...those walks are every bit as far as the hole lengths...

Default User Avatar
Commented on

Rees Jones should never be allowed to stick a shovel into any Tillinghast course unless you actually want to turn an exciting and creative masterpiece into a bland exercise for professional golfers.

Default User Avatar
Commented on

AMEN!!

Commented on

For some reason they altered the 18th hole this year. They defaced it by extending the right side fairway bunkering closer toward the tee. They said they did this to provide more challenge for pros who lay up. But the pros generally don't lay up that far back, and the heavy rough was already a substantial penalty. I don't understand that change. I do like the enlarged 11th green which they recently changed.

More from the author
8 Min Read
December 19, 2019
A year-by-year guide to an eventful decade in design.
6 Min Read
November 22, 2019
Beyond Pinehurst, the famed architect designed over 400 courses during his career. You don't need a membership or even a lot of cash to experience these works.
4 Min Read
November 8, 2019
The new WHS for 2020 brings changes to golf clubs and players. Here is what the USGA & R&A have updated and what it means for your index and handicap.
3 Min Read
November 5, 2019
An increase in extreme weather events is having an impact on golf courses all over the world, but there is no single way to adapt.
4 Min Read
November 1, 2019
One road connects two Donald Ross classics with modern efforts from Rees Jones and Arnold Palmer in Southern Pines
2 Min Read
October 28, 2019
New layout by Bill Bergin & Rees Jones is a dazzling addition to North Georgia golf.
Popular
12 Images
October 11, 2021
This Albuquerque gem is one of the tournament capitals of collegiate golf.
21 Images
September 30, 2021
This collection of photos sent in by reviewers might be the best we've ever seen.
7 Min Read
October 7, 2021
We found the 10 cities where it's easiest to score a tee time.
7 Min Read
September 30, 2021
From the largest elevation drop to the wildest greens and deepest bunker, all these U.S. courses take the game to the edge.
Load More
Now Reading
How major championship golf altered Bethpage Black