New York Country Club

NYCC was great. Tee-Up earlier than the actually time we had, Greens were magnificent, fast but Fair. The fareways were cut nice and short.
Some of the Tee Boxes were a little beat up.
I will definitely will go back.

izzy

you can only cart on this course
Very friendly staff
Free range balls on Friday
Tough course with many different shot types.

The course is set in the hills and has several great scenic views. Greens were true and traps were maintained. Some browning on the fairways which is unusual this time of year. All in all a good experience.

Just played the course 4/22/15. Just average remember thinking this is not worth $120.00 paid $55.00 that's about par for this course. Ground under repair leaves blowing around not what you would expect for country club.

The course is very nice but I think they should open the driving range .

Ok for location. greens had to much sand. Driving range closed. Staff very friendly.

Wish the greens had less sand, but i would like to come back and play this course in june or july

Played for the 1st time. Considering the winter, being able to play is fantastic. Greens were still mostly dormant with significant sand on most. Sand traps were mostly hard pan and it was cart path only - which is understandable. The course is not terribly challenging and with the conditions felt it was expensive even with the Golf Now discount. Not sure I would give it a second try. Average at best and expensive.

We were extremely fortunate to have planned a day of golf when it was 70 degrees on November 24th. The spring-like weather deep into the fall was lucky. The course was not crowded because it was a Monday and we played as a twosome in under 4 hours. Course had some well-protected greens but overall not extremely difficult from the white tees.

Unique hilly course. Course is very dependent on your tee off. It has to be straight and far. If you are a scrambler, it won't help you score here. You can't walk this course so definitely a "no" for those who prefer walking. Great views and wildlife.

close to the city, fairways were in good shape, greens were ok, good pace of play,accommodating staf. Overall good value.

After playing this course a number of times, and really enjoying it, it was surprising when I played in August how poor the course conditions were. Specifically the greens, which were taking a long time to come back, and they were reconstructing two greens.
I played this morning, and the conditions were absolutely pristine - greens were running true and fast, and the new greens were also in perfect shape. When off first and alone at 8:00am and rolled off the 18th at 10:45. Pure joy.
Go play!

Paid discounted price of $86 on a Sunday morning. The good first...staff were nice. The course has some nice views with a number of holes with downhill tee shots and uphill tee shots. Now the bad...the greens were not too great to say the least with a number of holes being aerated. Some holes looked like construction zones with fairways being torn up and wires hanging out from the ground on one hole. Also the whole layout of the course was very cramped...like on some holes you actually had to watch out for players teeing off on the adjacent hole as you are making your way to the green.

Overall I would not go back especially at this price point. Don't ever think about paying full price ($120).

Absolutely a course to play, a fun challenge, Need to play this more than once to learn what to do. Greens were slow but rest of course was in good shape == staff was very nice.

In the beginning of the summer, I would have given this course 4 stars. I have been playing it for about 2 years. The staff and facilities are great. There are some huge elevation changes on holes 1, 9, 10 and 18 as the clubhouse is on a huge hill overlooking the course below. Challenging and fun usually. This time around while the course was pretty empty and pace of play was great, the greens were almost all punched and bumpy making it impossible to post a good score. They did give out a ticket for a free beer/soda and a hot dog which was nice but if i had paid full price for this course ($120 in prime), I would have been livid. Look for a discounted tee time of $80 or less when the greens return to form and this place will be your favorite like it has been mine.

One of the most scenic courses around with interesting and challenging holes that reward good shot making. Played this course in June and it was in perfect condition. However, just a few months later in August I found the course in bad shape--not so much neglected by management, but by golfers failing to replace their divots and failing to fix their ballmarks on the greens. I doubt this was caused by the clubs members. So I would say that the management needs to make a greater effort to remind golfers and/or police this situation. No rangers were in evidence during either of the two rounds I played there this summer.

Don't play here for a while.
One of par3 is closed and whole course is on going process of maintenance. The worst part was the green they made a huge holes on the green for air which is never noticed on website. No sign. Utill we arrived the 1st green, never know about it.
paid 60 dollars per play not worth it. Not even 20 dollars.

I discovered NYCC in June and it is one of the most scenic and interesting courses around. Also it is a moderately challenging course that rewards good shot-making. In June the course was in pristine condition. However, this time around (two months later) I was appalled at the number of divots that had not been replaced on the fairways and number of ball marks not repaired on the greens. I doubt this damage was done by the club's members. It's a shame that such a beautiful course is allowed to be beaten up by visiting yahoos.

This course has some beauty, for sure. It is difficult because you are rarely on a flat lie and the greens were in terrible shape. They were at least three different speeds and many were diseased. I hope they figure out the problem because bad greens equals little enjoyment for me. #9 is a crazy hole too! The staff was friendly though and the food was good.

New York Golf Club has excellent facilities and a somewhat challenging course. The staff are extremely friendly and helpful. If only the week end rates where cheaper. Paying $120 for an 8am tee time means that this is a course I can only afford to play occasionally.