Bogeys and Boulders: Is Canada's Muskoka the toughest golf destination in North America?

GRAVENHURST, Ontario, Canada -- Lots of hazards scare golfers.

Water, bunkers, wild greens, narrow fairways, large trees and tall rough can cause havoc. When you combine all that, plus add exposed rock and dramatic elevation changes to the mix, well, the game gets crazy tough.

The Canadian Shield just might be North America's greatest defense against par. Muskoka -- a tourist region of lakes, cottages, resorts and courses two hours north of Toronto -- makes a strong case as North America's toughest golf destination. Four area courses (plus three others in Ontario) earned the dubious distinction to be ranked among Golf Advisor's 50 toughest courses as determined by online reviews from average golfers. No other state or destination had more than two.

I'm not surprised by the results. I lost a dozen or more balls playing every Muskoka golf course that made the top 50 during my only visit in 2012. I fell in love with the area's beautiful lakes and forests, but watching my ball ping pong off the rocks before flying out of bounds was a bit frustrating.

Many of the best courses play like target golf to the extreme. Golf architects couldn't really tame the land by blasting too much rock or filling in wetlands. They merely worked to find as playable a routing as possible through the natural terrain. Some were more successful than others. Here's a look at the area courses singled out in the Golf Advisor top 50:

36. Oak Bay Golf & Country Club

Location: Port Severn, Ontario, Canada
Yardage: 6,503 | Slope/Rating: 146/71.4
Architect: Shawn P. Watters
Comment: Oak Bay, expanded from nine holes in 2011, wanders through thick tree cover near the Severn Sound of the Georgian Bay. The 165-yard 15th hole epitomizes the beauty and beastly nature of Muskoka's courses. The elevated green sits on a gigantic granite outcropping above a marshy lake cove. It's a do-or-die shot that many players under club. Me included.

29. Highlands Course at Deerhurst Resort

Location: Huntsville, Ontario, Canada
Yardage: 7,011 | Slope/Rating: 140/75.1
Architects: Thomas McBroom, Bob Cupp
Comment: I'm actually a bit surprised the granddaddy of Muskoka's modern courses made the list. I'd vote for Taboo Muskoka over the more resort-friendly Highlands Course. The Highlands Course, built in 1990, features some fun elevation changes. Most of the exposed rock guards the perimeter of the routing not the actual playing corridors.

23. Muskoka Bay Club

Location: Gravenhurst, Ontario, Canada
Yardage: 7,367 | Slope/Rating: 146/76.1
Architect: Doug Carrick
Comment: Muskoka Bay was my favorite round of the trip. It is kept in country club condition. The routing was fair and interesting. I even found it in my heart to forgive Carrick for the controversial ninth hole, a par 4 that climbs uphill to a green hidden behind a pair of rocky shields that pinch the fairway from either side, allowing only a narrow opening to reach the green. Beginners and women who can't get the ball airborne hate the hole. For better players, however, the challenge to hit the perfect approach induces a burst of adrenaline.

22. The Rock Golf Club

Location: Minett, Ontario, Canada
Yardage: 6,649 | Slope/Rating: 144/72.0
Architect: Nick Faldo
Comment: The Rock gets five stars for scenery and only three stars for its design flaws. There are a few quirky holes plagued by blind shots and small target landing areas. You probably need to play it three or four times before you feel comfortable. I'd like to play it again before I pass full judgment if it should be avoided altogether.

Jason Scott Deegan has reviewed and photographed more than 1,000 courses and written about golf destinations in 20 countries for some of the industry's biggest publications. His work has been honored by the Golf Writer's Association of America and the Michigan Press Association. Follow him on Instagram at @jasondeegangolfpass and Twitter at @WorldGolfer.
Default User Avatar
Commented on

Muskoka also has some of the friendliest courses that are only as tough as you want to make them. Conditioning is world class. Venues are varied. And there are no rock outcroppings on many. Don't let this article leave you with the impression that Muskoka is all about tough. We are the soft entry to the wilds north of us. And our courses play well if you play well. 

Related Links

Muskoka Lakes has more top 100 public-access courses than any other golf destination in Canada. Picking the top five places to play here isn't easy, but Jason Scott Deegan has done it.
2 Min Read
In celebration of Canada day, we've got the 10 best golf destinations to visit this summer in the Great White North.
6 Min Read
Canada's most expensive public-access golf courses aren't cheap but cost significantly less than the two most expensive golf experiences in the U.S.
9 Min Read
More from the author
4 Min Read
November 21, 2022
More than $100 million in renovations and upgrades have Horseshoe Bay ready for your next golf getaway.
2 Min Read
November 20, 2022
New innovation brings unique products to improve the life of golfers.
3 Min Read
November 7, 2022
A club fitting with the TaylorMade Performance Center at the Pebble Beach Golf Academy can help you find a new favorite club.
1 Min Read
November 7, 2022
The YOC auction raises money to benefit junior golfers.
3 Min Read
November 2, 2022
Golf bachelor parties require the right mix of nightlife coupled with daytime rounds. We've found the best spots for your crew.
2 Min Read
October 31, 2022
Hitting golf balls into nature on purpose breaks the ethical code that golfers should leave the course - and its surroundings - better than how they found it.
7 Min Read
November 18, 2022
We cover every price point to make sure your favorite golfers get the gift they want this holiday season.
2 Min Read
November 7, 2022
Rory McIlroy, Shane Lowry and Morgan Pressel share their major-winning experience to help you play better.
7 Min Read
November 2, 2022
Both established resorts offer reliable Florida fall and winter golf getaways.
Load More
Now Reading
Bogeys and Boulders: Is Canada's Muskoka the toughest golf destination in North America?