Reviving this old-timey match-scoring system is a Cool Golf Thing

Some things 125 years old are new again.
Yale and Columbia's golf teams recently revived a 125-year-old rivalry with an interesting old-time twist.

How much time must pass before doing something a very old way becomes, effectively, a new way of doing that thing?

Is 125 years enough?

It might be, in the context of a recent tussle between two of college golf's oldest programs.

On October 22 at Saint Andrews Golf Club in Hastings-on-Hudson, N.Y., Yale and Columbia renewed the format of their very first meeting, held on November 6, 1896.

With seven players appearing for each squad, the two Ivies hewed to the seemingly anachronistic format that governed that first encounter: a total-holes-won scoring system where the players on both sides of each match play all 18 holes, even when one would otherwise be closed out. Playing their home course, Columbia avenged their lopsided 1896 loss by beating Yale, 15 holes to 2.

I see some advantages to this way of keeping score, as opposed to the Ryder Cup-style one-point-per-match scoring that dominates team match-play golf. It retains the hole-to-hole rhythms and excitement of match play, but rather than rendering the final several holes meaningless in a blowout, a losing player can still help his or her team by winning a couple late and closing the gap, which could make all the difference in the overall score. Winning one's match remains crucial, but playing hard for 18 holes takes on slightly more importance, too.

If I find myself organizing a large buddies trip in the future, I think I'll incorporate this format for one of the rounds, with the each member of losing team paying the winners a dollar or two per hole of scoring difference, just to keep things interesting.

6 Min Read
November 6, 2014
The Brits do it right -- match play, alternate shot, Stablefords, etc. -- to keep things moving. If you've had enough of stroke play, here are 10 suggestions.

Tim Gavrich is a Senior Writer for GolfPass. Follow him on Twitter @TimGavrich and on Instagram @TimGavrich.
Commented on

This is a very clever format that would seem to work better than the nonetheless tried-and-true Ryder system. 125 years seems quite a while for a readoption of this long-in-the-tooth scoring system, but hey, necessity is often the mother of renewal (in this case).

It’s interesting to see Columbia, where I played in the 70’s when their home course was Rockland Country Club, now playing at St. Andrews in Hastings-on-Hudson. The course looks to be a slight upgrade, maybe, from what was their former home turf. And their victory over Yale on October 22nd is yet another Cool Golf Thing.

More from the author
7 Min Read
December 3, 2022
From brand collaborations to limited drops to resort pro shops, there has never been more variety in apparel and accessories for golfers to choose from.
1 Min Read
November 30, 2022
Hit the clubhouse, make a birdie?
10 Min Read
November 28, 2022
Modern golf dominates the Sunshine State, but there are plenty of antiques - both polished and unvarnished - waiting to be unearthed by adventurous visitors.
8 Min Read
November 20, 2022
GOLF+, an increasingly popular virtual-reality golf video game, brings an impressive simulation of the game into your living room.
1 Min Read
November 17, 2022
How many strokes is Chuck getting, anyway?
3 Min Read
November 16, 2022
Las Vegas loves over-the-top luxury. This offer combines some golf with insider access to the 2023 Formula 1 race on the Strip.
3 Min Read
November 7, 2022
A club fitting with the TaylorMade Performance Center at the Pebble Beach Golf Academy can help you find a new favorite club.
2 Min Read
November 20, 2022
New innovation brings unique products to improve the life of golfers.
7 Min Read
November 18, 2022
We cover every price point to make sure your favorite golfers get the gift they want this holiday season.
Load More
Now Reading
Reviving this old-timey match-scoring system is a Cool Golf Thing