One-hit wonders: Ranking the best tropical islands with only one regulation golf course

LANA'I, Hawaii -- I've never thought of tropical islands with only one 18-hole course as true golf destinations. They're more like vacation getaways with golf, not for golf.

My recent visit to this secluded Hawaiian paradise blew away that misconception. Playing Manele Golf Course three days in a row enlightened me. I don't see myself ever growing tired of the Jack Nicklaus design routed along spectacular oceanfront cliffs.

Each time I played Manele, a new tee or pin placement added an intriguing twist. Although I teed off at the same time every morning, the tradewinds continuously shifted, sometimes mid-round, making certain holes play completely unique. I met another couple who planned to play the course every day for a week.

Lana'i is the best example of a tropical island with only one regulation course that's worth turning into an extended golf getaway. There are others, mainly located in the Caribbean. I've ranked them from best to worst to help you decide that age-old question: Should I bring the sticks?

1. Lanai, Hawaii

Comment: You don't have to stay at the Four Seasons Resort Lana'i to play Manele any more. If you do, the entire experience will cost you more than $1,500 - rooms are $1,000-plus per night and a tee time costs $325. The price tag is worth seeing what might be the best resort golf course in Hawaii. The resort closed the Koele Golf Course, Manele's sister track near the cooler climate of Lana'i City, several years ago with hopes of a renovation but announced in 2017 that it wasn't coming back. The island does have a free (albeit scruffy) nine-holer, the Cavendish Golf Course, set among the pines near Lana'i City as well.

Jaws drop on the 12th at #ManeleGC #fslanai #whyilovethisgame #LivingTheGreen

A photo posted by Jason Scott Deegan (@jasondeegangolfadvisor) on

2. Canouan Island, St. Vincent and The Grenadines

Comment: The front nine and the finishing hole of the 150-acre Grenadines Estate Golf Club at Canouan Resort stretches across flat coastal plains with holes 11-17 climbing 480 meters above Carenage Bay to the cliffs of Mount Royal.

3. Great Exuma, Bahamas

Comment: Similar to Manele, the Sandals Emerald Reef golf course is a scenic stunner that serves as an amenity of a five-star resort, the Sandals Emerald Bay, an all-inclusive luxury hotel that used to be a Four Seasons property. Greg Norman designed Emerald Reef through a mangrove swamp on the front nine before a spectacular stretch of windy holes tours the rocky shore on a narrow peninsula.

Jaws drop on the stunning par-3 13th hole at #sandalsemeraldbay #GregNormandesign #Bahamas #wow #Thursdayscramblechampions

A video posted by Jason Scott Deegan (@jasondeegangolfadvisor) on

4. Anguilla

Comment: The Norman design at CuisinArt Golf Resort and Spa starts out with an eye-popping view of St. Maarten and the Caribbean Sea from the first tee. More visual fireworks continue with a double green for holes no. 2 and no. 10 set along the Anguilla Channel. The Jumeirah hotel chain out of Dubai has long been linked to an 18-hole Nicklaus project called Forest Bay, but nothing has come to fruition.

5. St. Kitts and Nevis, West Indies

Comment: St. Kitts and Nevis -- two small Caribbean islands that are one nation -- each boast an outstanding 18-hole course worth playing. St. Kitts won't be a one-trick pony for long. The Ian Woosnam-designed course called Kittitian Hill is somewhat playable, but it's not in great shape as the owner continues to cling to the idea of an all-natural golf course with no chemicals. It's not working thus far. I have great memories of playing the island's original course, Royal St. Kitts Golf Club, a par 71 redesigned by Canadian architect Thomas McBroom in 2004. I shot my career low round the first time I visited and later finished third in a pro-am in 2017.

The golf course at the Four Seasons Resort Nevis, a 1991 Robert Trent Jones II design, garnered five stars from Golf Advisor contributor Adam Stanley. It is just a ferry ride away from St. Kitts. A rudimentary 12-hole, par-3 course called Cat Ghaut Chip N Putt is located near Charlestown, the capital of Nevis.

6. Aruba

Comment: A pair of nine-holers -- Aruba Golf Club and Links at Divi Aruba -- complements Tierra del Sol, a par-71, Robert Trent Jones Jr. design on the island's northwest tip. It is managed by Troon Golf. It's also set in the shadow of a lighthouse.

7. Grand Bahama Island, Bahamas

Comment: The Reef course at the Grand Lucayan, an RTJ2 design from 2000, is the only surviving 18-hole course on the island. Water comes into play on 13 holes. Fortune Hills Golf & Country Club was meant to be a full course but only nine holes were built.

8. Providenciales, Turks and Caicos

It's tough to lure tourists away from the award-winning beaches of Grace Bay, but Provo Golf Club still accomplishes the task, even though it lacks the dramatic ocean views of other Caribbean golf courses. Karl Litten gouged the island's rocky terrain to create the course in 1992. NBC Golf Analyst David Feherty serves as its spokesman.

9. St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands

Comment: Short but sweet, the 6,022-yard Mahogany Run Golf Course is a narrow, challenging course cut from the island's Blue-Bit stone by George and Tom Fazio in 1980. Even President Bill Clinton has taken on the Devil's Triangle, a three-hole stretch highlighted by the par-3 14th sitting 200 feet above a rocky inlet on the Atlantic Ocean.

10. St. Lucia

Comment: St. Lucia Golf Club, set within the scenic rolling hills of Cap Estates, was created from an old nine-hole routing. The all-inclusive Sandals Regency La Toc Golf Resort & Spa, meanwhile, allows free play for guests on its nine-hole course.

11. Martinique

Comment: Empress Josephine Golf Course at the Martinique Golf and Country Club was named after Napoleon Bonaparte's wife. It is a 6,640-yard, par-71 design by RTJ Sr. dating to 1976. The official language of the island is French, so holler "devant" not "fore" when you hit one astray.

12. Cuba

Comment: Cuba could become the Caribbean's next golf hotspot. The island has a history with the game, hosting a PGA Tour event before Fidel Castro seized power in 1959 and bulldozed the host course. Varadero Golf Club, a resort course two hours from Havana built by Canadian Les Furber, operates out of a clubhouse that was once a mansion for the Du Pont family called "Xanadu." The nine-hole Havana Golf Club is closer to the capital city.

13. Cozumel, Mexico

Comment: Cozumel Country Club, a 1991 Nicklaus design, was routed among coral outcroppings, lagoons and mangrove swamps on the island directly across from Playa del Carmen of the Yucatan Peninsula. It remains a favorite of golfers arriving by cruise ship. It has received reviews from one to five stars on Golf Advisor.

14. Grand Cayman, Cayman Islands

Comment: The interesting thing about the largest island in the Caymans is the nine-hole Ritz-Carlton Golf Club, a Norman design adjacent to the Ritz-Carlton Grand Cayman, is kept in better shape than the island's only full course, North Sound Golf Club, a 6,605-yard par 71. There's also another nine-holer by Nicklaus called Britannia.

15. Grande-Terre Island, Guadeloupe

Comment: The Golf International of St. Francois is RTJ Sr. design featuring eight holes protected by water.

Editor's Note: Baker's Bay, a private club in The Bahamas was not considered. Neither were the Hawaiian island of Molokai (Ironwood Hills) and Grenada (Grenada Golf Club) -- two islands that only offer nine holes each.

Jason Scott Deegan has reviewed and photographed more than 1,000 courses and written about golf destinations in 20 countries for some of the industry's biggest publications. His work has been honored by the Golf Writer's Association of America and the Michigan Press Association. Follow him on Instagram at @jasondeegangolfpass and Twitter at @WorldGolfer.

Related Links

St. Kitts and Nevis are idyllic escapes that are equal parts out-of-the-ordinary and a flashback to a simpler Caribbean time. And the golf scene here may very well become the best in the Caribbean.
4 Min Read
The two premier tournament hosts in the Bahamas -- The Abaco Club and Sandals Emerald Bay -- are the perfect winter golf escape.
6 Min Read
A number of top courses in the Caribbean have hosted pro events. Here's where to find tour-worthy golf and a good dose of sunshine.
8 Min Read
Since 2008, no Caribbean island has invested more time, effort and money into its golf scene than Puerto Rico -- and it's paying off. There are 21 golf courses currently open in Puerto Rico, led by Trump International Golf Club, which hosts the PGA Tour's Puerto Rico Open.
8 Images
Perched high on the cliffs overlooking the Hulopoe Bay and the Pacific, Jack Nicklaus' Manele Golf Course is among the game's most stunning venues.
11 Images
If you could play golf this winter, which island would you tee it up on? Hawaii? The Bahamas? Jamaica? Bermuda? Jason Scott Deegan reveals a dozen of his favorite island escapes in winter.
7 Min Read
More from the author
4 Min Read
September 24, 2023
New equipment and fashion - plus a handy tool for fall golf - highlight this month's report.
4 Min Read
September 24, 2023
Tim Gavrich and Jason Scott Deegan go point/counterpoint over whether retaining the cup is a satisfying result.
5 Min Read
September 20, 2023
The effort it takes to reach Sea Ranch is rewarded with never-ending Pacific Ocean views and rugged, minimalist golf.
3 Min Read
September 19, 2023
The year-long project created a new 7th hole and expanded fairways, greens and approach aprons to balance championship golf for the pros with fun for the members.
4 Min Read
September 17, 2023
Fortinet fans are spoiled with burger dogs, weekend concerts and the chance to get up close to the players.
4 Min Read
September 14, 2023
Here's a look at the history of golf handicaps, how they are calculated, and where you can get one.
21 Images
August 28, 2023
Summer golf's finale heads overseas to discover some cool courses most Americans probably don't know much about.
10 Images
September 10, 2023
The Robert Trent Jones Jr. design overlooks Bodega Bay, the site of Alfred Hitchcock's horror movie classic, 'The Birds'.
15 Images
September 18, 2023
We previewed the inventive 19-holer, which has begun taking tee times for Dec. 1, 2023 and beyond
11 Images
September 22, 2023
The course David McLay Kidd designed more than a decade ago is finally ready for its official opening October 5th.
Now Reading
One-hit wonders: Ranking the best tropical islands with only one regulation golf course