Phillip J. Rotella Memorial Golf Course

Staff behavior here was beyond the pale in terms of rudeness. While exiting 2nd hole, an employee screamed at me for almost a minute because my cart was parked a foot off the cart path. The hole was not marked cart path only. I would have had no problem if he had just asked me to move it or keep it on the path in the future but, as a customer, I don't expect to be verbally assaulted, for any reason. This guy was stark raving mad.

Also, the pro shop would not take Amex for greens fees and had I not happened to have just enough cash to pay, I would have had to turn around after making a thirty mile trip. First time I have had an Amex card not accepted at a course in the NY area (maybe there are others that don't take it, I don't know). If this course is going to take bookings through GolfNow, there needs to be some kind of notification to customers that they don't accept all major charge cards.

As for the course, it is average at best with its main virtue it being fairly close to Manhattan. Neighboring Patriot Hills and NYCC are both much better tracks.

My husband and I had never played up in this area of NY and didn't know what to expect. We were very pleasantly surprised with this course. The greens and fairways were in good shape just wish people would learn to fix their own divots. There were some tricky holes which were elevated and/or had a hidden green. The only complaints I would have are 1-we teed off 30 min late and 2-we had a foursome in front of us and amongst them were two VERY new golfers and we didn't feel that the Ranger kept a very good eye on them nor did he ask them to move along hence our 5+ hour round. But, we would definitely play this course again. I am sure it is beautiful in the fall with all the trees changing colors.

Positives - tee boxes and fairways in really good shape. Greens in good shape but very slow.
Negative - staff - no one to be found outside for a while and finally got some instructions. Greens slow. Pace of play was a little below average but no ranger to be found to help.
I will return because I enjoyed the course except for one hole (can't remember the #) Par 5 with no landing zone - one side of the fairway straight up a hill the other side straight down. Just felt like they tried to squeeze a hole in. Other than that - I enjoyed the layout very much.
Will return.

Enjoyed the course - had some interesting carries and lay- ups - made it a challenging yet fun day - staff was friendly - good pace of play - excellent conditions - greens ran fairly true - would definitely play there again

Great Course a little pricey, a specially for winter rates

Well maintained fairway/greens compare to other courses in the area. Great value for the money (their Burger was tasty and included in the rounding fee)!! Will go back to play!!!

It,s ok. There are condition is ok, but green condition is not good.

first time 0ct.28. what a beautiful course. i'm 30 handicap but enjoyed round.

The staff is courteous very friendly. The course is very nicely laid out and challenging. I played a 3pm tee time on a Saturday (Oct 26) and was very surprised by a 1 hour back-up at the 4th tee. Fortunately no one was behind us and we were able to re-play #'s 2 and 3 holes. After 3 hours we called it quits at 9 holes since we were running out of daylight. I suppose if possible it is better to try playing on a weekday here instead if possible.

GREAT LAYOUT, EXCELLENT CONDITION, NICE STAFF, GOOD BAR AND FOOD, PACE OF PLAY EXCELLENT, GREAT VALUE. Need I say more

Nice muni course with challenging holes. Pace of play was the issue but was allowed to finish in the dark!