Pelham Bay at Pelham/Split Rock Golf Course

I consider this my home course. I love the staff, the layout and the value of the course. HOWEVER my Uncle and I were put with 2 walkers who decided that every rule had to be followed. Mind you we went out at 10:46 am. The place was packed and we had to deal with two men who didn't want to play "ready golf" and who decided to look for every ball that got lost in the leaves. Just drop a ball and don't take a stroke!

Sucked because I really love this place, however being paired with slow players and being stuck behind a foursome who thinks they are on the PGA tour really sours things. The ranger drove bus 3 times but didn't seem to be engaged or aware of what was going on on the course.

Good length and tight fairways.

Nice layout, 4 hour round on a Saturday. Close to NYC

For a public course. In the Bronx, no less.

Lucky to have an early morning tee time on a weekend so the notoriously slow pace wasn't a factor this time. This course is one of my favorites due to its layout which will make you use just about all your clubs in your bag. Playing from the back, tee shots must be placed well and accurate as well.

Condition wise, the course has seen better days. I know this and a Pelham gets a ton of play but that means it should have enough funds to keep it in decent shape. The sister course (Pelham) is even worst. Anyway, since this place is a cash cow course maintenance isn't the highest priority.

First time playing split rock this year in terrible condition

the weather was wonderful, so we headed out to our favorite public course. unfortunately so did everyone else. the course is usually long to play or slow paced. this Saturday it was beyond a snail pace. there was a wait to tee off and about a 10 to 15 minute wait per hole. this was exceptionally long due to two outings booked on the same day. but it caused unusual delays all the same. the fairways were well kept, but a few of the greens were beat up. no Bueno.

all and all a fine day but we ended up having to pack it in after the 14th due to darkness.

My god, played this track just over two weeks earlier and man does it make a difference. I've seen this course in pristine conditions so it's really shocking to see the shape it's in now. Teeboxes, and a good portion of fairways were beaten up and pretty much sandboxes. Greens weren't in the best of shape but still rolled ok and actually playable. If it wasn't for the location, friendly staff and great specials this place has, I can't imagine anyone paying full price to play here.

Fun course, forgiving on tee shots. I known this place gets a ton of play but that should mean it has enough funding to maintain it in decent conditions. Most tee boxes were dirt/sand boxes and greens (more sand boxes) rolled horrible. Fairways were no better. With course conditions, this place is hit or miss. Not complaining too much because they give great specials with lunch and carts during the weekdays. I can't imagine paying full price to play here. Staff is always friendly and give you warning during check in. Place is a cash cow but they to show concern towards customers. And last, bring bug spray.

INot enough space to share my SADNESS in playing the course today. Our 10:00 tee time went out at 10:45 due to a morning outing running late. On the 9th hole the ranger drove up to our group yelling we were holding up the course ( someone needs anger management class). Truth was he had another outing waiting to go out and he had several groups still out on the course due to the late start. Three hours to play the front nine. So we get to the 10th tee to find we are the fourth, yes, the fourth group waiting to tee off. We opted to head to the Pro Shop to complain to the GM only to find he/she was no where to be found (hiding maybe). The only positive point I can add was our lunch was delicious. Think twice about playing this course as they seem to be more concerned about overbooking tee times than customer satisfaction.

the course had three temporary greens and for the money it was not worth it.

I've played each course here one other time.

This was the worst I've seen it. Several greens were scorched and temporary "winter golf" ones set up.

Golf pro shop employees were inattentive, didn't mention the greens issue and were more interested in sharing something on their iPhones.

Previous times were much better, can't say if it's a one off or not.

I played well so I was pleased overall but . . .

Overbooked, terrible, 45 min per hole terrible experience, didn't get to finish a round of golf. Front 9 took 5 hours. Each hole had 3-4 waiting at the tee box. Done playing this course overall and staff doesn't care, just money hungry. Nothing was attempted to move things along.

The course was in poor conditions. Some tee boxes were rock solid and barely able to jam a tee into the ground. Lots of dead spots throughout and poor conditions. Not worth the full amount.

It would be helpful in making a decision to play if the course would notify golf now about temporary greens. 4 of 18 is a lot with the remainder dressed.

I always say I'm not playing here, they mess at least something up every time but this is the last time for sure.

1st time playing they overcharged us on the golf now rate and when we showed them the email they said they couldn't refund it they'd have to give us credit. I can't believe that, what company can charge cards and take cash but can't give refunds? Anyway they gave us receipts and said our names were in the system for the credit. Next time I went they did not honor the credit.

2nd time we teed off about an hour late, you'd think for $70 on a course that only averagely/ poorly kept they would at least respect your tee time and not overbook like crazy but they don't care.

3rd time got through 14 holes in just under 6 hours and we skipped a head to see if we could jump in anywhere and there was a group the 16th green with the group ahead of them pulling up to the 18th green. The rangers don't do anything, they just drive in circles all day. On top of that the greens are poorly kept and covered in sand all the time.

By far the worst valued course I've ever played on and its expensive and the staff doesn't know what they're doing.

Challenging course. Long and narrow but very fun! I'd like to try Pelham Bay next time since I've heard it's a bit more forgiving. The lunch + 2 drinks deal is solid!! Pace of play was OK (this was a sunday afternoon so it was expected).

My opinion the most challenging tracks amongst the NYC public courses (not counting Trump). Had an early tee time so pace was great. Considering the amount of play this place gets, conditions are playable. If the tips are pushed back, you must be a big hitter unless you're looking to play for lay ups on the harder holes. To me the front 9 plays a bit tougher due to more narrow fairways. One thing Pelham bay is know for is for its super mosquitos. Despite practically pouring bug spray all over myself, these super mosquitos still bite and manage to bite through clothing as well.

Well maintained great value

Weekends could take 4-5 hours but during the week pace is very good

Current deal with 2 beverages and lunch a no Brauner

The layout for Pelham Bay is definitely quite easier than Split Rock but still enjoyable. There are minimal hazards, open fairways, but greens still have plenty of undulation. Conditions are acceptable from tee box to fairway. Green conditions/speed vary from hole to hole but overall in good condition, just need each one to be consistent.