Declawed: New holes on Raptor Course at Grayhawk Golf Club in Scottsdale, Ariz. drawing mixed reviews

SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. -- Whenever a golf course is redesigned to make room for redevelopment, a red flag of concern has to be raised.

Rarely does the course come out better on the other side. Add the celebrated Raptor Course at Grayhawk Golf Club to the list of courses that have been scarred by a future housing development.

The Raptor, originally built in 1995, debuted a new three-hole stretch -- no. 15- No. 17 -- last October. Original designer Tom Fazio rerouted holes 15 and 16 and shortened the 17th hole within its original footprint to allow access to a plot of land that is zoned for development. The club indicated in a press release that there are no plans for building "on the horizon, (but) the renovation ensures that when the time comes, it can be accomplished without interfering with play."

That interference has already taken place. The new holes are being met with mixed reviews. Golf Advisor user danielcbelanger gave the course three stars after seeing the new holes last October. He called the new par 3 at no. 16 "one of the ugliest-designed, par-3 holes for a 'championship' course that I have seen in the valley."

He expressed his displeasure, writing: "I am not sure if I will play Raptor in the future, as I think the new design has been poorly planned and executed. It cheapens an otherwise beautiful and challenging course. Too bad!"

I wasn't overly impressed, either, after playing the Raptor during the final round of the Scottsdale Open in January.

The new routing now makes a U turn after the 14th hole, so that no. 15 runs parallel in the opposite direction. The new 437-yard hole -- which replaces a drivable par 4 -- gives off a good first impression. Two bunkers up the left side of the fairway dominate the view from a slightly elevated tee. The fairway bends right to a tricky green featuring several ridges. It's a solid newcomer.

However, the new 16th hole, a 151-yard par 3 that replaced a much longer one, feels like filler. I wrote in my Golf Advisor review that it's an "eyesore" that looks completely out of place. A front bunker covers the right side of a green, and that's it. It's pretty bland, like eating oatmeal after 15 holes of cheesecake. Every other par 3 on the course is so much better.

The new 17th hole remained a par 4, shrinking in size from a stout 464 yards to a drivable 331 yards. Again, it's a cookie-cutter effort that could have been so much more interesting. The lone bunker near the green isn't really even reachable for most players, who will bang a driver or wood to set up a simple wedge to the original, elevated green. Why not throw in a couple of risk-reward cross bunkers or pinch the fairway tighter with other obstacles?

Thankfully, the course returns to glory for the final hole, a risk-reward par 5. The pond near the 18th green sets up great theater for a tournament. Players who have already completed their round can watch the drama unfold from the chairs and patio near the clubhouse.

Are the changes so awful that I'll never play the Raptor again? Hardly. It's still got some of the best par 5s (nos. 4 and 18) and par 3s (no. 8, named "Aces & Eights") in Scottsdale.

The club's biggest draw remains intact -- its fun, energetic vibe thanks to Phil's Grill, the bar dedicated to Mickelson, and the music jamming on the range. It's a lively atmosphere few public golf courses can match.

The Raptor might have lost a few teeth, but the former host of three Andersen Consulting World Championships (a precursor to the WGC-Accenture Match Play Championship) in the 1990s and the PGA Tour's Open from 2007-09 still boasts enough bite to keep golfers happy most of the time.

Let us know your thoughts about the renovation in the comments below or in a separate customer review.

Jason Scott Deegan has reviewed more than 1,000 courses and golf destinations for some of the industry's biggest publications. His work has been honored by the Golf Writer's Association of America and the Michigan Press Association. Follow him on Instagram at @jasondeegangolfadvisor and Twitter at @WorldGolfer.
More from the author
6 Min Read
December 7, 2021
Part of the legendary teaching family, Harmon has paved his own path with an emphasis on improving the average amateur golfer.
4 Min Read
December 3, 2021
It's never been easier to design custom hats, golf balls, clubs, headcovers and more.
4 Min Read
November 30, 2021
The Jamaica Invitational Pro-Am "Annie's Revenge", one of the Caribbean's best pro-ams, introduces the fun and the sun of Rose Hall near Montego Bay.
4 Min Read
November 23, 2021
We scoured the web of golf and found holiday savings up to 50% off.
4 Min Read
November 22, 2021
Anyone can play Tom Fazio's Wynn Golf Club, which sits in the heart of the Las Vegas strip.
7 Min Read
November 11, 2021
More than 115 golf resorts can be booked using your Bonvoy rewards. We break down where you can go and our favorite properties to use your points.
5 Min Read
November 20, 2021
Help the golfer in your life shoot lower scores, look and feel better than ever this holiday season with these eight golf gifts.
2 Min Read
November 15, 2021
Rory McIlroy, Phil Mickelson and world-class instructors help you get up-and-down more often.
12 Min Read
November 18, 2021
Golfers can choose from a wide variety of portable launch monitor price points and user experiences. Here is what's new and the best ones to consider to improve your golf.
1 Min Read
December 3, 2021
It's good to sweeten the pot.
Load More
Now Reading
Declawed: New holes on Raptor Course at Grayhawk Golf Club in Scottsdale, Ariz. drawing mixed reviews