Restoring a Ross rendition

Golden Age designs evolve over time. The same goes for their modern replica holes.
The par-5 13th hole (left) at Boyne Highlands' Donald Ross Memorial, a rendition of the 15th hole at Seminole Golf Club, is in line for a makeover.

For a course featuring 18 renditions of holes from all over the world, one of the things I like the most about playing the Donald Ross Memorial at Boyne Highlands Resort is for the fact it feels so cohesively "Northern Michigan."

Having played a handful of the original Ross designs from which the course borrows (from Royal Dornoch, where he grew up, to his triumph at Pinehurst No. 2), my takeaway was that, whether you care to examine the originals down to the inch or not, it's just a flowing and quiet round with some exciting golf shots and solid variety of greens.

The Ross Memorial was built during the 1990s golf resort boom in Northern Michigan. The story goes that Boyne founder Everett Kircher, longtime Boyne Sr. VP of Golf Operations Bernie Friedrich, architect Bill Newcomb and Jim Flick traversed the globe visiting and playing over 50 Ross courses. Oh, to go back to 1990s R&D budgets in golf!

The Ross Memorial helped usher in a roster of replica-style courses during the 90s boom years of rapid growth of resort and upscale "destination" golf courses coast-to-coast (see also: Architects, Tour 18, Renditions, Bear's Best, World Tour, etc.).

What's notable is that at this point in time, replicas were being created based on original holes that themselves had been extensively modified since their early days. For example, The Ross Memorial course culminates with one of the most infamous holes in the Ross portfolio: The 16th hole at Oakland Hills South. But that course was toughened by Robert Trent Jones, Sr. prior to the infamous 1951 U.S. Open when Ben Hogan "Brought this course, this monster, to its knees."

The Ross Memorial's 18th is built off the challenging 16th hole at Oakland Hills South.

As we've cruised through the leaner and meaner 21st century of golf course architecture, restoration and renovations have trumped new course builds. A new breed of neoclassic architects has studiously studied Golden Age designs and uncovered their original presentations and philosophies thanks to early aerial photography or site plans. These studies typically revealed fewer trees, wider fairways and bolder, larger greens.

The project that really ignited the movement was Coore & Crenshaw's restoration of Pinehurst No. 2 prior to the 2014 U.S. Open from its grassy and manicured state that evolved in the 1960s and 70s back to its wispy, sandhills original nature of Ross' time. It unleashed a wave of Carolina Sandhills Ross renovations. Kyle Franz restored Ross' other famous resort courses at Pine Needles and Mid Pines, and is currently doing the same to Southern Pines. Gil Hanse was tapped by Pinehurst ownership to bring Pinehurst No. 4, which bordered the throwback No. 2, back to a similarly rugged, sandier aesthetic.

Scores of historic private clubs with Ross and other Golden Age designs have aggressively sought out top historians and architects to restore their layouts, and that includes Donald Ross' Seminole Golf Club in Florida, site of this week's Walker Cup host. Coore & Crenshaw recently worked their magic here to help bring out Ross' original intent.

9 Min Read
May 4, 2021
Get to know this storied South Florida golf club, host of the 48th Walker Cup Matches.

Updating the Ross Memorial at Boyne Highlands

If historic courses are being renovated out of their modern, manicured states back to its more original intent, shouldn't replica courses follow suit? That's the idea at Boyne Highlands. They've enlisted Michigan architect Ray Hearn to enhance many of the holes into an even more authentic appearance. Among the first holes getting a facelift is the opening hole, inspired by the relatively short, par-4 6th hole at Seminole. While the proposed revision doesn't exactly match up with Seminole's, it's clear Hearn intends to transform many of the treed areas into something more open and sandy - something that not only feels more like South Florida but also adds a pleasing sense of place off the first tee of this property that isn't far from Lake Michigan.

Achieving an exact match would require most notably a subtle change in green angle and moving the cart path right of the green to add more turfed area near the bunkers. The closer Hearn can ultimately come to achieving authentic Ross shot values here and on other holes (the Memorial has two holes rendered from Pinehurst No. 2 - the par-4 2nd and 14th holes - that will require a similar de-turfing and sanding to achieve an accurate appearance), the more fruitful it will be for the legacy of the Memorial and architecture enthusiasts will take notice.

The target may always be moving. After all, Hanse was just tapped to renovate Oakland Hills, so upon completion there, the Ross Memorial's closer will need re-examination.

Northern Michigan has enjoyed a renaissance of golf catering to the classic architecture crowd, fueled by the success of Mike Devries' private throwback, the Kingsley Club near Traverse City and the resurgence of Willie Watson's 1920s semi-private Belvedere Golf Club. In the last five years, Dana Fry opened Arcadia Bluffs South, a course that pays homage to the style of C.B. Macdonald and Seth Raynor. Tom Doak built The Loop at Forest Dunes in a reversible and bouncy fashion akin to the Old Course at St. Andrews. The destination's splashy, challenging modern resort courses of the 1990s are stepping aside to make room for these more classically inspired designs. The combination of the two styles has kept Michigan near the top of the most coveted golf destinations in the world.

49 Min Read
May 3, 2021
Oh, the places you can go in pursuit of all the pleasures golf has to offer.
6 Min Read
August 31, 2020
In our current era of neoclassicism and nuance in design, novel concepts of previous decades remain popular.
August 5, 2019
There's no better Midwest getaway in the summer than Northern Michigan. Brandon Tucker helps pare down your trip into a jam-packed, five-day itinerary that features golf along Lake Michigan in in the hills around Gaylord.
Golf Packages
Savor the marvelous destination that is Northern Michigan and enjoy up to 36 holes a day during the long summer days! Our Boyne golf package features exceptional flexibility and selection thanks to two of the state's finest multi-course golf resorts.

Brandon Tucker is the Sr. Managing Editor for GolfPass and was the founding editor of Golf Advisor in 2014, he was the managing editor for Golf Channel Digital's Courses & Travel. To date, his golf travels have taken him to over two dozen countries and nearly 600 golf courses worldwide. While he's played some of the most prestigious courses in the world, Tucker's favorite way to play the game is on a great muni in under three hours. Follow Brandon on Twitter at @BrandonTucker and on Instagram at @btuck34.
Commented on

The question for me is: What constitutes an “authentic appearance” for the replica courses? In the case of this Ross replica at Boyne Highlands, ‘authentic’ should mean a hole that is a closer replica to Seminole’s than Mr. Hearn’s plans show.

The re-design shows improvements, but do they go far enough? The addition of sand traps on the fairway’s left side certainly brings the green back into play when you’re hitting at it from this area--much more than the dense tree growth has, up until now, allowed. But of course, Ross’ Seminole design had no trees at all on the left side. Maybe it’s quibbling, but I’ll assert that a hole that is already quite hard (landing in these bunkers is just one example of its difficulty), and doesn’t need the extra trouble when your drive veers left. To me, this kind of stuff compromises (at least a bit) what could be a stronger replica, making the way it plays somewhat irrelevant to the great designer’s original intent.

Excellent and thoughtful article--especially because it’s not, perhaps, the kind of area most golfers will consider. But at a big-bucks resort, someone needs to do so. It’s good to see that the owners at Boyne are working at it. In the final analysis, actually playing the revised hole, after it’s done will prove whether or not the changes are good ones.

More from the author
7 Min Read
October 7, 2021
We found the 10 cities where it's easiest to score a tee time.
2 Min Read
September 28, 2021
In a new exclusive series from GolfPass, Rory McIlroy demonstrates with Martin Hall how to hit the 9 shots. Here's how to add them to your practice routine.
9 Min Read
September 23, 2021
We've crafted a Dream 18 from the most exciting holes in American public golf.
7 Min Read
September 21, 2021
Large buddies groups love playing Ryder Cup-style, multi-day team events on their golf vacations. And what could be more epic than playing a Ryder Cup match on a former (or future) Ryder Cup venue?
2 Min Read
September 21, 2021
Bernhard Langer recalls the turning point that led to a European wave at the Ryder Cup matches
4 Min Read
September 10, 2021
Pete Dye's golf course designs set the bar for innovation, creativity and challenge. We've compiled his top courses as rated on Golf Advisor by regular golfers like you.
12 Images
October 11, 2021
This Albuquerque gem is one of the tournament capitals of collegiate golf.
21 Images
September 30, 2021
This collection of photos sent in by reviewers might be the best we've ever seen.
3 Min Read
October 4, 2021
America's largest golf resort, and one of its smallest, are expanding to enhance the guest experience.
3 Min Read
October 7, 2021
Recent releases run the gamut from irons to apps.
Load More
Now Reading
Restoring a Ross rendition