Mystery Valley Golf Club

Fairway conditions were great but green conditions could not be worse. Greens felt like you were putting on dirt that were spray painted green. Tee boxes were overall in decent condition but there were a few that were practically all dirt

Just dropping a review to make anyone playing after 4/20/2025 aware of the greens. I am not sure what happened and how long it will take to recover but we were not made aware of the fact that every inch of every green is basically gone. The fairways were running pretty fast but each and every green was just unplayable. Putting was somewhere between cement and a game of Plinko. We love this course and will return, just not until the greens have grass on them again.

This course is such a great layout and such a good deal, but it stops there. After completely renovating their greens one year ago, as of today, they are unplayable and probably the worst greens in the greater Atlanta area. Even though I’ve played this course more than anything else in the area, I will not be returning.

Furthermore, they completely mismanage their tee sheets on the weekend. They decided that Saturday is a good day for their men’s league to play. This leads to additional groups being added and players starting on the back nine, so they need to make the turn right at the busiest part of the day.

This course has such potential, but the greens are in terrible shape. Hardpack sand.dirt and weeds populated far more of the green than any grass. They need to close for a while and regrow them. I won't be back this year.

Let me start by saying I have played here 30+times, I like the layout, the staff, the course etc but the greens are in terrible condition. I cannot recommend paying to play here until that changes and unfortunately it looks like it may be many months before they will improve. Very disappointing because I really enjoy playing Mystery Valley.

The greens were not in good shape. It made for a long day. I’m not exactly sure what is going on with the greens. It was like putting on packed dirt, sand and grass all rolled up in one. I would love to come back when the greens are in better shape.

I had the chance to play the Mystery Valley with my son in April. I loved the course design but could tell from the conditions that it had not yet recovered from the colder winter weather. Greens were fast due to lack of grass but were still pretty true. I would love to play the course again.

1.5 hrs in called it quits after almost getting 3 holes in. No pace of play management. Pretty unreal cannot suggest this course. Staff was friendly, greens were sanded can’t speak much about layout b/c I couldn’t wait 8 hrs to get a feel for the course.

Not sure what happened to greens replaced in last couple years, hope they recover. Probably not go back until greens improve. Maybe consider offering a price break considering greens current conditions. Staters helpful by allowing us to go off back to help with pace of play, 3.5 hrs round.

Had a good time playing fairways were nice, but the greens are in bad shape will be a month or so before they’re right

Pace of play was terrible on a Tuesday morning. Sr groups held the back 9 up. On the front 9, a 5-sum played together.

The greens were bumpy but the fairways were decent.

All and all I would play there again because of the great course layout. Hopefully the greens and pace of play is better.

Yes, some of the grass is still dormant, and there are a lot of leaves. To the naked eye the greens look rough, but they roll very true. Considering the time of year, I would say the course is in great shape, especially for the price.

I haven’t golfed here for about three years. I used to come all the time before kids. The tee boxes and greens are in absolute garbage condition. You can not gauge a putt distance nor speed because they play like plinko. Do not spend money here.

Golf carts are in terrible condition. Brakes were a challenge. Greens were horrible. Tee boxes need work. I don’t recommend this course

Terrible greens and fairways. Bunkers are nice. A tee time should be half they are charging.

This is a good course for beginners/intermediate level golfers.

Very enjoyable round at this old Dick Wilson course. The routing takes the golfer on a roller coaster ride through the rolling terrain and the surrounding forest.

Course conditions were good and the rolling greens were close to perfect.

Poor online booking tee time. Whoever books online has to pay the service fee of $7 plus sales tax for the total cost of the round. In my case it was approximately $8 , for a threesome. When we got to the course they charged each member of the threesome an equal amount of the remaining balance for the round. Since I had already paid $15 the attendant would not split the total cost of the round, leaving me to deal with getting reimbursed for their share of the service fee and the sales tax. They could have reversed my booking costs and then charged each of us an equal amount.