Cimarrone Golf Club

Have been playing this course 20+ years, seen several owners/evolutions to the course. New owners last June with years and years of PGA logistics/operational experience. Promised to redo the entire course makeover/Clubhouse reno.

In that year the tee boxes/fairways have made great improvement, clubhouse currently in a complete reno but looking fantastic.

However, the greens for the most part are unplayable. 3-4 look fairly nice and green, the rest are a mix of good grass/dirt/sand/weeds. Several greens have "half and half" good grass and dead grass, some have 4' wide strips of sod running the length that you have to putt over/through which is near impossible.

And the grass that is used is like sticky flypaper. You expect a 10 foot putt but it's lucky if it rolls 4-5 feet, and that's on the GOOD portions.

After a year of rework, it would be expected the greens would be top priority and looking AND playing well but sadly not. Love the course but right now it's really not playable to any form.

I love this place because it’s so doggone difficult,

if you can defeat hole number two, and hole number 10, you’ve got yourself a good game

but the greens, they’ve never been good for years and I just wish I knew why. it’s like putting on shag carpet mixed with sand and fresh sod.

the other fairway is acceptable.

but green is terrible and they changed green grass type. they tried maintenance

but even if the turns to good shape, it will be so slow and not a normal green. just like carpet.

so disappoint.

Greens had more sand on them than the bunkers. Could not putt on any green.

Teeter green it's in great shape. Several greens are unputable other greens are good in spots but still bear. It still need some help it's improving but not there yet

The fairways seem well managed. The greens are in process of significant repair. The staff continue to be friendly.consideringvthevprice, I think this is a good value with some challenging holes.

I loved this course but the last few times I played here there has been huge deterioration in course conditions particularly the greens which are now almost unplayable

Won’t be going back till they’ve been fixed

It’s such a shame because the staff are great and the course has so much potential and I am sure the club house will be great when the renovation is completed

Please work on the greens to gain my custom back

I love the course layout and challenges of this course; however the green have been in bad shape for years.. Don’t anticipate playing there again until Greens are in better shape!

Greens and bunkers are atrocious. Wouldn't have paid more than $20 considering the course conditions.

Saw the 4.5 stars rating and thought what I’d heard about new ownership putting money into the course had taken hold. Yeahhhh…NO. Memo to the owner: DUDE…golfers will put up with about most anything…except crappy GREENS.

And they’re crappy…as in not a SINGLE ONE was even CLOSE to playable. Y’all should be arrested for larceny charging people what you’re doing to play this place.

Lesson learned…I will NEVER give you another DIME of my money. FOR SHAME.

Don’t play here this course is in terrible condition. I would wait at least a year to play here.

Good lay-out and friendly staff. The tee boxes are in good condition. Fairways are below average. The greens are the absolute worse I have ever seen and I have been playing for 50 years. Will not return

Big difference from last time we were here - little over a year ago. The greens were mostly bald, fairways OK. I thought our golf cart would die before 18 holes - the cart seized on us 3 times with a sudden stop.

Very disappointed overall. They need to fix this course to remain viable in St Johns as there are other courses to play nearby.

We had to take 3 carts because one of our party had to leave early. We ended up getting rained out, staff asked for an extra 25 cart fee. I'm okay with it, but it's a bit tacky on a 345pm tee time. Course is I'm better shape than I've seen it in a few years, a couple of greens under repair. Greens are slow, but decent.

A terrific layout, beautiful fairways. The greens are playable and you can see the effort they are making to repair them. I highly recommend this course and I think it will continue to improve. Make sure you play from the tee box that fits your game. The further back you are, the course is just that much tougher and accuracy is a must. I'll be back for sure!

2nd time I’ve played here course is challenging. But the place is under renovation. They will give you a play next time at half price coupon. Which I will be using soon. Greens where jumpy. Hopefully they get everything smooth, but then again, me and my buddies aren’t that good. We just out for a good time, which it was.

Improved since last time I played… appreciated 9 hole rate

Challenging course with water, sand and moguls

However about half the greens were in poor shape