Michigan golf resorts gobble up the competition

Four Michigan golf resorts have purchased nearby courses to enhance their allure for guests.
A view from a tee at the Charlevoix Country Club.

Northern Michigan is home to some of the largest golf resorts in the world.

Treetops, Garland, Boyne Highlands, Shanty Creek and A-Ga-Ming all boast at least 72 holes. The growth of Forest Dunes and Arcadia Bluffs as resorts - both have added a new second course and more lodging in the last five years - have made it that much tougher for standalone courses to survive in such a competitive market. There's been a lot of interesting consolidation the past five years as smaller resorts look to keep up with the big boys. They're buying up more local courses than ever before.

In Gaylord, the Loon Golf Resort has expanded exponentially, first taking over the nearby Lakes course and then buying the former Marsh Ridge Resort and renaming the property The Ridge in 2015. A-Ga-Ming has only joined the list of northern Michigan mega-resorts in the past couple of years. The purchase of Antrim Dells in 2012 and the addition of the Charlevoix Country Club in 2017 gives it as diverse a golf offering as any 'up north' resort. On the west side of the state, the Double JJ Resort in Rothbury acquired the Grand View Golf course in nearby New Era in 2017.

More recently, the Riverwood Resort in Mount Pleasant just finalized the purchase of the Pines at Lake Isabella in May, giving that mid-Michigan destination an additional 18 holes. "The Pines is a wonderful course and it was a great opportunity for the Riverwood family to grow," owner Dick Figg told the Morning Sun newspaper. "We're excited about merging two fine golf courses and all the possibilities it presents for members and open play."

Why buy?

The first hole at the Loon Golf Resort in Gaylord introduces players to the target-style challenges

By all accounts, the golf business is tough sledding, even before the coronavirus pandemic hit, and especially so in an oversaturated market like Michigan. So why are local resorts spending big to expand? The answer has multiple layers: 1, To eliminate local competition. 2, To create more enticing stay and plays that offer variety and potentially keep golfers on property longer. 3, To keep up with the Joneses.

Boyne Resorts - stocked with three distinct resort properties - has long had a grip on northern Michigan's golf vacation scene. Having eight stellar courses, ranging from the sporty Alpine and Monument courses at Boyne Mountain Resort to the splendors of the 27-hole Bay Harbor Golf Club, has made its "Great Escape" package the gold standard of golf getaways. For $999, a golfer gets unlimited rounds for five days, the ultimate golf binge. There are shorter packages available for the less maniacal player.

Michigan Golf Packages
With more than 650 courses, Michigan claims to be "America's Summer Golf Capital." Browse golf packages to this Midwestern summer golf mecca.

With this consolidation trend, the smaller, complementary golf resorts that are growing no longer hide in the shadows. I had a front-row seat to the impressive expansion of The Loon in 2010 when new owners built a townhome village consisting of four-bedroom/four-bathroom units featuring full kitchens just steps from the clubhouse. I brought a foursome to the pro-am that celebrated Butch Harmon's slight redesign of the course. Harmon, who has taught Tiger, Phil and many others, was super-friendly and a great storyteller. Adding the Ridge gives the Loon a lot more space for guests with multiple hotel-style rooms, suites, lodges, cabins and free-standing condos, all within walking distance to the Summit Grill. The course itself is super short at 6,231 yards but is one of the more beautiful and fun experiences in the Gaylord Golf Mecca.

The most curious move has to be A-Ga-Ming's takeover of the Charlevoix Country Club, which is a half-hour from the resort. That facility is more of a private club with a fitness center and pool. It must be going well enough, because the onsite restaurant, Shanahan's Pub, was revived in 2018.

The standalone courses thriving or surviving?

I've played nearly 200 courses throughout Michigan, but I do have a black hole - many of the family-owned courses 'up north' not connected to a resort. Like most golfers, I would go to a resort and play its courses for a story or on a golf package. That left little time and energy to drive off-property to find more golf.

I regret having moved out of state without playing Charlevoix CC and Dunmaglas, located six miles apart in Charlevoix. Both get rock-solid reviews from Golf Advisor users: Charlevoix a 4.3 average star rating and Dunmaglas 4.5. Whenever I'm in that area, chances are I'm teeing up Belvedere anyway, the old-school classic where Tom Watson played during summer vacations as a kid. It has hosted more Michigan Amateurs (40 some) than another other course in the state.

Another one I've missed is the Little Traverse Bay Golf Club & Restaurant, which was less than five miles from Boyne Highlands in Harbor Springs. Sadly, it's gone, having sold in April to transform into a 280-acre nature preserve, according to mlive.com.

In mid-Michigan, I'm still hoping to someday play Bucks Run (13 miles from Riverwood) and Apple Mountain in Freeland (20 miles from Bay Valley Resort in Bay City). In recent years, Island Hills, a scenic Raymond Hearn course in Centreville, has developed golf villas that I've heard are really nice.

Another interesting pocket of lesser-known tracks not affiliated with a resort surrounds Traverse City. You could easily stay at Crystal Mountain in Thompsonville or The Homestead in Glen Arbor - two of my family's favorites - and play some intriguing local tracks that have escaped me. Pinecroft Golf Plantation in Benzonia (12 miles), Mistwood in Lake Ann (20 miles) and Interlochen (20 miles) are near Crystal Mountain, while the Leelanau Club at Bahle Farms (24 miles) in Suttons Bay and the nine-hole Northport Creek Golf Club (30 miles), the world's only solar-powered golf course, reside in the beautiful Leelanau Peninsula somewhat near The Homestead.

I'll leave you with this, a list of cool, individually owned courses I HAVE played that are within driving distance of some fine Michigan golf resorts. Maybe this will spark your interest to explore off-the-beaten cart path. I wouldn't be surprised if one day at least one of these courses was acquired by a nearby resort or faced closure like Little Traverse Bay or Elk Ridge in Atlanta. Not that I have inside knowledge that any of them are struggling or looking to sell. It's just the way things are trending these days. Surviving solo is no easy task in a region dominated by mega resorts.

Jason Deegan's favorite non-resort courses "up north"
East Tawas, Michigan
Public
4.7647294118
7
Bellaire, Michigan
Public/Resort
4.6387470588
252
Bellaire, Michigan
Public/Resort
4.2823058824
104
Mount Pleasant, Michigan
Public
4.5146176471
110
Brutus, Michigan
Semi-Private
4.3914823529
60
Ludington, Michigan
Public
3.7083333333
10
Vicksburg, Michigan
Public
4.75
18
Saugatuck, Michigan
Public
4.8032
303
Pierson, Michigan
Public
4.7530470588
184

* Hidden River Golf & Casing Club in Brutus 12 miles from Boyne Highlands.
* Hawk's Eye and The Chief in Bellaire right across the street from Shanty Creek's Summit Village.
* The Ravines in Saugatuck 20 miles from the Hawkshead Inn in South Haven.
* The Hemlock in Ludington 20 miles from Manistee National Golf & Resort in Manistee.
* Pilgrim's Run in Pierson 30 miles from Tullymore Golf Resort in Stanwood.
* The Pohlcat in Mount Pleasant 8 miles from Riverwood.
* Angels Crossing in Vicksburg 28 miles from Gull Lake View Resort & Club in Augusta.
* Red Hawk in East Tawas 20 miles from Lakewood Shores Golf Resort in Oscoda.

What Michigan resorts and courses do you love visiting when you're 'up north'? Let us know in the comments below.

Jason Scott Deegan has reviewed more than 1,000 courses and golf destinations for some of the industry's biggest publications. His work has been honored by the Golf Writer's Association of America and the Michigan Press Association. Follow him on Instagram at @jasondeegangolfadvisor and Twitter at @WorldGolfer.
9 Comments
Default User Avatar
Commented on

Michigan is truly America's Summer Golf Capital. Been there many times, starting with Boyne's Great Escape which is the best value in golf, bar none. I could spend all day talking about great tracks which are also great bargains. Great summer weather, too. Go, if you possibly can. I love writing travel articles about Michigan golf. I'm one of their biggest fans.

Default User Avatar
Commented on

I’ve played Bear Lake Highlands and The Heathlands (Onekama) pretty extensively. A few miles inland from Arcadia, not architecturally significant but quite a few pretty and challenging holes each and usually in excellent condition. Heading back in a couple weeks to Arcadia South Course & the rest of my old haunts.

Default User Avatar
Commented on

Wow, sad to hear about Little Traverse Bay. I have been visiting up.north for 40 years and played most of the courses you mentioned. Love Belvedere and the Hills course at Boyne Highlands has become a favorite. Too many to mention. I get a kick out of hearing raves for Florida, North Carolina, etc. and gave no idea what a pleasure northern MI golf is.

Default User Avatar
Commented on

You had better get over to Grand Haven and check out American Dunes Golf Club which will open in the spring of 2021. It will be the home course for the Folds of Honor and is a Jack Nicklaus signature golf course, on the site of the old Grand Haven Golf Club.

Staff
Commented on

I do look forward to this new addition. The old course wasn't memorable. Hopefully this one is. It seems ripe for some stay-and-play cottages.

Default User Avatar
Commented on

It was pretty good when it opened in the mid 1960's, but it grew old over the years. American Dunes will be a significant improvement. Talked with some of the guys who worked on the course and they had some very high praise for it. It is also for a good cause, the Folds of Honor.

Default User Avatar
Commented on

You didn't mention Manitou Passage Golf Club in Cedar MI. quite close to Traverse City. It is an Arnold Palmer design course next to the abandoned Sugar Loaf ski resort.

Staff
Commented on

I didn't mention it b/c it is owned and operated by Homestead. I shouldn't have assumed everyone has heard of it and knew that. It's a great place to play, for sure.

Default User Avatar
Commented on

One of my favorite courses anywhere is Lake Michigan Hills, a few miles south of South Haven along I-196. Challenging layout with some big elevation changes that used to host a qualifier for the Western Amateur. It had gotten a bit scruffy a few years back but was much improved when I last played it in 2019.

More from the author
4 Min Read
September 16, 2021
Some of the world's famous venues are littered with sand.
3 Min Read
September 9, 2021
Putting from off the green can save strokes (and headaches) if done properly.
3 Min Read
September 7, 2021
From cooler weather to wide open tee sheets, there's a lot to love about a fall golf trip. View our top destinations.
4 Min Read
September 1, 2021
While the boom has been great for the industry, it's been tougher on golfers looking for tee times.
3 Min Read
August 30, 2021
Sand Hollow is the headliner for "Greater Zion," a Utah destination in the midst of a mini-golf boom.
3 Min Read
August 24, 2021
Playing nine holes every Sunday helps Bob Williams stay sharp, physically and mentally.
Popular
21 Images
August 31, 2021
Flowers, castles and sunsets highlight the best photos from our users in the last hurrah of summer.
3 Min Read
September 16, 2021
Golf course news and notes: September, 2021.
4 Min Read
September 10, 2021
Pete Dye's golf course designs set the bar for innovation, creativity and challenge. We've compiled his top courses as rated on Golf Advisor by regular golfers like you.
1 Min Read
September 17, 2021
R.I.P. to a legend.
Load More
Now Reading
Michigan golf resorts gobble up the competition